Comparisons.us is a comparison website - we do not rank or rate products. We do come up with pros and cons based on publicly available comments and feedback. Our goal is to provide consumers with the information they need to make informed decisions. When you call, click on or purchase something on Comparisons.us we may receive compensation. As an Amazon Associate Comparisons.us earns from qualifying purchases. Additionally, we do not list every product or service available in each respective category.

Ice Shelters

  • Lightweight and built from durable materials
  • Optimized fishing space
  • Boat seat style which is perfect for fishing
  • Super warm and comfortable
  • No warranty
  • Product is expensive
Key Features
Specifications
  • Super warm and comfortable
  • Easy to set up and use
  • Made from durable materials
  • No warranty
  • Product is known to be expensive
Specifications
  • Designed for aggressive ice fishing hole hopping
  • Panoramic front window and improved window material for clear view
  • Comfortable seating and amazing insulation
  • Convenient functionality
  • Limited warranty
  • Ice shelter has limited space
Key Features
  • Frabill Ice fishing gear | Since 1938, Frabill has been trusted to position anglers for success
  • The Ice Hunter Sidestep Flip-Over Shelter is designed for aggressive ice fishing hole-hopping | Incorporates consumer research, pro-staff feedback and field study
  • CLEAR VIEW: Panoramic front window and improved window material for clarity & durability
  • COMFORTABLE SEATING & INSULATION: Quilted insuation, plush boat seats and sturdier seat bases with less flex
  • CONVENIENT FUNCTIONALITY: Frabill's patented entry system, large interior gear pockets, molded glove-friendly zipper pulls and additional reflective material for safety | Dimensions: Setup - 84" L x 58.5" W x 64" H | 20 Fishable Sq Ft
Specifications
Warranty
  • Super warm and comfortable
  • Product is not small so you can fit many people
  • Easy to set up and use
  • No warranty
  • Space is limited
Key Features
Specifications
  • Super warm and comfortable
  • Optimized fishing space
  • Ideal for super cold conditions
  • Lack of warranty
  • Takes awhile to set up
Specifications
  • Equipped with ice lock anchoring
  • Provides greater downforce security and reduces wind lift
  • Amazing wind protection
  • No warranty
  • Slow delivery
Key Features
  • All Otter shelters are equipped with our exclusive ice-lock anchoring System
  • This 3-point corner anchoring System provides greater downforce security and reduces wind lift
  • All Otter shelters are equipped with our exclusive ice-lock anchoring System
  • This 3-point corner anchoring System provides greater downforce security and reduces wind lift
  • 2 overhead Cargo storage nets (XTH Pro cabin includes 1), 2 propane hose ports with hook & loop flaps (XTH Pro cabin includes 1)
Specifications
  • Oversized, trip proof door which means you cannot trip
  • Many fishable areas so you can fish within your tent
  • Fully insulated
  • Limited warranty
  • Slow delivery
Key Features
  • Oversized, trip-proof door - the outbreak 450I is uniquely designed with an oversized, trip-proof door that fully Zips down to the ice. This means no more catching you foot on the door framework and stumbling with your gear.
  • More fishable area - flared, wide-bottom design provides significantly more fishable area than other shelters on the market.
  • Fully-insulated - IQ insulated fabric is 35% warmer than a comparable non-insulated shelter.
  • 600 Denier IllumiDark Gray Interior - Gives an angler the best of both worlds—it brightens the interior making it easier to see and fish, but also has light blocking PU backing that still gives the angler the ability to close the windows.
  • Stronger hub design - The outbreak 450I features an all-metal ball-and-socket design as well as larger fiberglass poles.
  • Portability - everything fits into an oversized cinch duffle bag.
  • Removable window panels - adjust your shelter’s ventilation with detachable hook and loop window panels.
  • Mesh storage pockets - keep your essential fishing gear handy & out of the bottom of the sled.
  • Deluxe tie-downs and In-skirt grommets - deluxe, Cam strap tie-downs are included for rugged, solid anchoring in windy conditions. Ice anchor grommets are Now included directly in the shelter skirt for Convenience.
  • YKK Zippers - Quality, durable, industry-preferred zippers—standard on all Eskimo ice shelters.
  • Included Components: Ice Anchors
Specifications
Warranty
  • Durable to withstand any element
  • Reliable quality
  • Easy to set up and use
  • Lack of warranty
  • Expensive delivery
Key Features
  • The leader in the ice-fishing industry offering a full line of hardwater fishing supplies
  • Durable to withstand any element
  • Reliable quality
Specifications
  • Comes also with a ice auger
  • 300D fabric keeps the wind and weather outside and the heat inside
  • Precision ground high carbon steel cutting blades rip through ice
  • Product is expensive
  • Limited warranty
Key Features
  • Powerful 33cc 8 inch Ice Auger AND Bonus 2 man portable shelter in ONE package!
  • 33 cc two cycle engine with 8 inch auger
  • 76" hub to hub shelter
  • 300D fabric keeps the wind and weather outside and the heat inside
  • Precision ground high carbon steel cutting blades rip through ice in seconds
  • Super easy to set up
  • Amazing ventilation and view
  • Can fit up to 5 to 8 adults
  • Carry bad is included
  • Lack of warranty
  • Product is heavy
Key Features
  • ✅EASY SETUP: A popup ice tent that can be easily set up and broken down in only seconds with the help of the illustrated instructions.
  • ✅VENTILATION & VIEW: Equipped with double doors and 4 PVC transparent windows for ventilation and view.
  • ✅ROOMY TENT: Spacious and tall ice fishing tent can fit up to 5 to 8 adults. Spacious enough to place your other fishing or heating supplies inside.
  • ✅CARRY BAG INCLUDED: Easy to transport in the carry bag when fully folded, and this tent weighs only 36.3 lbs.
  • ✅DIMENSION: Overall dimension: 141.75"L x 70.75"W x 70.75"H,Folded dimension: 51.25"L x 9.75" W x 9.75" H
Specifications

Ice Shelters Overview

Ice fishing is becoming more and more popular recently because of the beauty and calmness of the lake during winter, Ice fishing used to be something that barely anyone did but now it has become a sport. Maybe you are looking to start ice fishing as a hobby or maybe you are an experienced ice fisher looking for new gear but the most important item to ice fish is an ice shelter. Ice shelters ensure you are warm and safe during the cold winter days and nights while ice fishing

Ice shelters are super important because without a shelter you freeze and ice fishing cannot be enjoyed, you can either buy an ice shelter that you can fish in if needed or an ice shelter that you will use as a portable home on ice, both are great options but they depend on your preference. Other options other than ice shelters are incredibly difficult to set up and to move around if your fishing spot is not good. Ice shelters are the best way to stay warm while fishing.

Ice shelters are widely available and can be found at any utility store like Canadian Tire or Walmart but usually, you can find the best deals online, especially on Amazon. Fishing season is starting soon so this might be your last opportunity to buy a shelter before it's too late. You can find many deals right now because many companies want to clear out before the season which works to your advantage. To ensure you get the perfect shelter, we have compared the top ice shelters and listed the pros and cons of each. We hope you find our website informational and useful.