is a comparison website - we do not rank or rate products. We do come up with pros and cons based on publicly available comments and feedback. Our goal is to provide consumers with the information they need to make informed decisions. When you call, click on or purchase something on we may receive compensation. As an Amazon Associate earns from qualifying purchases. Additionally, we do not list every product or service available in each respective category.

Ice Cream Makers

Whynter Upright Stainless Steel Bowl Ice Cream Maker

Make delicious, customized homemade ice cream with the Whynter ICM-201SB 2.1 Quart Upright Ice Cream Maker. You can create ice cream, rich creamy gelato & sorbet all in the comfort of your own home.

  • Well designed and built to last
  • Does not take up a lot of room in counter
  • Makes various ice creams, frozen yogurt, and gelato
  • Well worth its price tag
  • Fast, Quiet and easy to use
  • User manual is not detailed enough
Key Features
Audible Timer

Cuisinart Compressor Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

Make decadent ice cream, Gelato & Sorbet, all in the comfort of your own home with the easy to use, fully automatic Cuisinart ICE-100 Ice Cream and Gelato Maker with commercial-style compressor.

  • Incredibly easy to use
  • Freezes quickly and stays frozen
  • Consistent results each time
  • Easy clean up
  • Very low maintenance
  • Gets pretty loud when churning
Key Features
Audible Timer

White Mountain Electric Ice Cream Maker

Whether you want an ice cream maker for home or a machine that will stand up to the demands of a commercial kitchen, the White Mountain ice cream maker allows you to create frozen treats with ease.

  • Very high-quality and easy to set up
  • Freezes quicker than many other makers
  • Worth spending the extra money for it
  • Looks very nice in the kitchen
  • Recipes in book are great
  • Motor is quite loud
  • Takes up a lot of counter space
Key Features
Audible Timer

Costway Ice Cream Maker

Enjoy delicious DIY Ice Cream at home. The Costway Ice Cream Maker allows you to make 2.1qts of your favorite ice cream in a single batch w/out taking up valuable freezer space for frozen desserts.

  • Looks great and is nice and light
  • Delivers great tasting frozen treats with little effort
  • Solidly built and easy to clean
  • Makes Ice Cream fast and easy
  • Great value for the price
  • Touch panel is too sensitive and easy to press by accident
  • Not as quiet as described
Key Features
Audible Timer

Cuisinart Pure Indulgence Ice Cream Maker

What's better than 1 quart of delicious homemade ice cream? 2 quarts! The fully automatic Cuisinart Pure Indulgence makes 2 quarts of your favorite frozen desserts in as little as 25 minutes.

  • Consistently smooth results with easy cleanup
  • Great for making smoothies as well
  • Seems very well made and durable
  • Made a gallon of ice cream in only an hour
  • Lightweight and easy to move and/or store
  • A little too noisy
  • Have to pre-freeze the bowl in order to keep ice cream cold
Key Features
Audible Timer

Ice Cream Makers Overview

Everyone loves Ice Cream in some form or another. Whether in a cone, a bowl, a sundae, cake, shake or sandwich, it is one of the favorite summer treats for many people. It is not only a great indicator that summer is on its way, but also a refreshing way to manage the heat. While there are many different places you can go to buy Ice Cream like Grocery Stores, Ice Cream chains, or your local Mom & Pop Ice Cream shop, for many people there is no better option than making your own.

There are countless brands and flavors out there to choose from but, as with anything produced for the masses, many lack the richness and taste that a good homemade Ice Cream has. Plus, many Ice Creams on the market contain additives and sugars that not everyone is aware of or interested in. That's where the Ice Cream maker comes in. You have full control over the ingredients used and flavors produced and can prepare it exactly the way you want. Much like the other food you prepare every day, you have the control over what you put into your body.

Another great thing about owning your own Ice Cream Maker is its versatility. You're not just limited to making Ice Cream as most can make great Gelatto, Frozen Yogurt, Sorbet, Smoothies and more. So whether you've been making your own Ice Cream for years and are looking for a new machine, or you're just now venturing into Ice Cream making and buying your first machine, we're here to help you make the best choice for you.

Types of Freezing Methods

When determining which Ice Maker is best for you there are a number of factors to consider. Size, Color and Price are all important things to look at but perhaps the most important is the freezing method. There are 3 main options out there to choose from when it comes to freezing, the traditional Rock Salt and Ice model, the Freezer Bowl model, or the internal Compressor model.

Rock Salt & Ice Models

The Rock Salt & Ice method is the most traditional way to make Ice Cream. While it has seen other methods developed over the years, this still remains the easiest and least expensive type of Ice cream Maker on the market. As it's name suggests, these machines use Ice to help freeze the product and salt to allow the mixture around the Ice Cream to get colder. These machines also use a crank to manually mix the Ice Cream.

Freezer Bowl Models

The Freezer Bowl Method is also self-explanatory. It requires you to put a bowl in your freezer for a period of time to freeze the bowl before filling it with the cream for churning. This can be an effective way to make Ice Cream but does have its limitations. First, it requires freezer space just to prepare for making the product. If your freezer space is limited, this can be an issue. Plus you are limited to making just one batch as it would require freezing the bowl again before making a second batch.

Compressor Models

The easiest and, as a result, most expensive model is the Compressor machine. These allow you to churn multiple batches of Ice Cream without any freezing preperations. The Compressor starts freezing immediately and can churn automatically. All you need to do is fill it up, press a button and wait for it to finish. If you make Ice Cream regularly and in abundance, this is the option for you.