Comparisons.us is a comparison website - we do not rank or rate products. We do come up with pros and cons based on publicly available comments and feedback. Our goal is to provide consumers with the information they need to make informed decisions. When you call, click on or purchase something on Comparisons.us we may receive compensation. As an Amazon Associate Comparisons.us earns from qualifying purchases. Additionally, we do not list every product or service available in each respective category.

Dog Food

Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets NF

Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets NF Kidney Function Canine Formulas are made with a restricted amount of high-quality protein and restricted phosphorus.

Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Balanced nutrition to help support the kidneys.
  • Restricted amounts of high-quality protein, low phosphorus levels, and a reduction in sodium
  • Designed for dogs with chronic renal failure, hepatic disease associated with encephalopathy, or any condition that benefits from restricted sodium levels
Product Dimensions / Weight

Royal Canin

Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Canine Multifunction Renal Support + Hydrolyzed Protein dry is a highly palatable, highly digestible, complete and balanced adult dog food.

  • Returnable within 30 days in most cases
  • Dog owners say their dog's love the taste!
  • Proven to help maintain the skin’s natural barrier
  • Pricey
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Reduced levels of highly digestible protein and restricted phosphorus to reduce stress on the kidneys
  • Patented skin barrier blend with optimal amounts of B vitamins and amino acids
  • Formulated with highly digestible, hydrolyzed soy protein and manufactured with stringent safe guards
Product Dimensions / Weight

ORIJEN Senior

ORIJEN's Biologically Appropriate Senior dog food nourishes your dog as nature intended by focusing on their biological need for fresh meat and a protein-rich diet.

  • Positive impact on dog’s digestion
  • Promotes lean muscle mass and a healthy body weight
  • 2/3 of the animal proteins in this premium dog food are fresh or raw
  • Features healthy fruit and vegetables delivered fresh and whole from Kentucky farms and orchards
  • Not ideal for little dogs
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Biologically Appropriate, grain-free dog food for senior dogs
  • Fresh and raw animal ingredients from 6 different sources: free-run chicken and turkey, wild flounder, cage-free eggs, Atlantic mackerel, and Atlantic herring
  • 85% meat inclusions; 15% vegetables and botanicals; 0% grain
  • Features WholePrey ingredients in ratios that mirror wild prey
Product Dimensions / Weight
  • 28.4 x 15 x 4.5 inches ; 24.9 pounds

Ohana Puppy Formula

Ohana provides optimal nutrition for puppies using high concentrations of EPA & DHA from fish oil and algae to promote brain maturation and development.

Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Gluten free
  • Uses coconut flour and banana powder with a mix of inulin and FOS (prebiotics)
  • High concentrations of EPA & DHA from fish oil and algae
Product Dimensions / Weight
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Gluten and grain free dry dog food
  • Made without corn, wheat, soy, or artificial fillers that can trigger chronic inflammation and illness
  • Ingredients meet all the nutritional levels established by AAFCO.
  • Uses wild-caught herring or anchovy to bypass the risk of heavy metal contamination
Product Dimensions / Weight

CANIDAE PURE

CANIDAE PURE premium dry dog food is made with real food ingredients, formulated for all dogs, and those with additional sensitivities.

  • Supports healthy digestion, a healthy immune system and beautiful skin and coat.
  • Great for dogs with sensitive stomaches
  • Great for fussy eaters and dogs with allergies
  • Non returnable
  • some report that formula is not consistent with each bag
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Limited ingredients crafted from 7-10 real foods in each bag
  • No wheat, corn, or soy
  • Probiotics added to every kibble after cooking
  • 6 different proteins (Salmon, Lamb, Duck, Boar, Bison Chicken)
Product Dimensions / Weight

Fromm Four-Star Chicken A La Veg

A specially prepared dish of lean chicken with fresh carrots, broccoli, cauliflower, and other fresh produce.

Dog Life Stage
Key Features
Product Dimensions / Weight

CARNA4

Carna4 is the synthetic-free "true food" that provides a ready-to-serve alternative or addition to home cooked or raw food diets.

  • Convenient – Easy-To-Serve Alternative To Raw Or Dehydrated Diets
  • Safe : Tested For 15 Pathogens And Toxins
  • Baked instead of extruded
  • Returnable within 30 days
  • Expensive
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Lightly Cooked True Food Ingredients, Grown In Canada And U.S.A
  • Contains Meats In Their Natural State
  • Quarantined For 2 Weeks While tested For 15 Pathogens And Toxins Including Salmonella, E. Coli, Aflatoxins & Mercury
Product Dimensions / Weight

Bully Max High Performance

Bully Max 30/20 is a high-protein, high-calorie food formulated to fuel your dog’s performance by giving him or her the energy they need to look and feel their best.

  • Helps to increase weight
  • Users report increase in dog's energy level and shinier coat
  • Positive impact on bowel movements
  • Some owners reported that their dog's had allergic reactions
  • Some complaints about the product being over-priced for size of bag
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Uses real meat as the #1 ingredient.
  • More calories than any other formula in its class (535 per cup)
  • Suitable for adult dogs and puppies (ages 4 weeks and older).
  • Tested 3 time prior to leaving the manufacturing facility
Product Dimensions / Weight

Nutro Wholesome Essentials

This dog food contains calcium to build strong bones and joints and omega 3 fatty acids like DHA to support the growth and development needs of your large breed puppy.

  • Great Taste And Helps Support Strong Muscles
  • Encourages shiny coat
  • Produces consistant stools
  • Buyers report that product is cheaper on Amazon compared to retail stores
  • Lack of of consistency between batches
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Contains one (1) 30 lb. bag of NUTRO WHOLESOME ESSENTIALS Natural Puppy Large Breed Dry Dog Food Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe; Natural Dog Food Plus Vitamins, Minerals and Other Nutrients
  • Made With Calcium To Build Strong Bones And Joints And Omega 3 Fatty Acids Like Dha To Support Healthy Growth And Development
  • Contains essential Antioxidants, Such As Vitamin E, For A Healthy Immune System
  • Made With Non-Gmo Ingredients* *Trace Amounts Of Genetically Modified Material May Be Present Due To Potential Cross Contact During Manufacturing
Product Dimensions / Weight

Nutro Wholesome Essentials Senior

NUTRO WHOLESOME ESSENTIALS Natural Senior Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe Dry Dog Food always starts with great tasting, farm-raised chicken.

  • Omega 3 & 6 Fatty Acids Promote Healthy Skin And A Soft, Shiny Coat.
  • Easy to chew
  • Keeps stools regular
  • Many positive reviews from buyers
  • Non returnable
  • Some report an over-powering fishy smell
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Contains one (1) 30 lb. bag of NUTRO WHOLESOME ESSENTIALS Natural Senior Dry Dog Food Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe; Natural Dog Food Plus Vitamins, Minerals and Other Nutrients
  • Designed To Maintain Cognitive Health And Contains Essential Antioxidants To Support Your Dog'S Aging Immune System
  • Made With Non-Gmo Ingredients* *Trace Amounts Of Genetically Modified Material May Be Present Due To Potential Cross Contact During Manufacturing.
Product Dimensions / Weight

K9 Natural

Premium freeze-dried dog food using only the highest quality ingredients.Innovative freeze-drying process removes only water, so all other nutrients remain in the food, including the taste.

  • Supports heealthy skin, coat condition & boosts nutritional value of your dog’s food In seconds
  • Filler Free, Gmo Free, Animal Meal Free, Artificial Preservative Free, Artificial Flavor Free And Artificial Color Free
  • Raw Freeze Dried & Easy To Use
  • Great for small dogs with sensitive stomachs and older dogs with problems chewing
  • Non returnable
  • A bit expensive
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
Product Dimensions / Weight
  • Good quality ingredients with limited grains
  • Great value for the price
  • Smell
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Crafted from chicken meal and rice providing an optimal level of nutrition for all breeds and sizes.
  • No wheat, corn or soy
  • Probiotics added to every kibble after cooking
  • Uses simple, whole-food recipes made in Texas facility.
Product Dimensions / Weight

Merrick Backcountry 96 Real Beef Can Dog Food

Merrick Backcountry 96% Real Beef Is An All-Natural Grain-Free Ancestral Canine Diet For Dogs Of All Life Stages And All Breeds.

Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Grain-Free Loaf Recipe Is Ideal For Dogs With Food Sensitivities
  • Case Of 12 Guaranteed Analysis: Crude Protein: Min 10% Crude Fat: Min 3.5% Crude Fibre: Max 3% Moisture: Max 78% Calories: 861 Kcal/Kg, 313 Kcal/Can
  • Loaf Recipe
Product Dimensions / Weight

Purina ONE SmartBlend Vibrant Maturity Senior 7+

Give your senior dog the nutrition that he needs along with the taste that he loves with Purina ONE SmartBlend Vibrant Maturity Adult 7+ Formula dry dog food.

  • high-quality source of protein
  • Nourishes and helps promote mental sharpness
  • Helps to support his healthy joints
  • Some report that their dog won't eat it
  • Some report too many tender morsels
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
Product Dimensions / Weight

Fromm Four-Star Salmon Tunalini Dog Food

A grain-free recipe made with fresh wild salmon and tuna with a medley of Mediterranean garden vegetables.

  • Buyers report that product is consistently delivered fresh
  • Smells good
  • helps with digestive health
  • Expensive for size
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Formulated To Meet The Nutritional Levels Established By The Aafco Dog Food Nutrient Profiles For All Life Stages
Product Dimensions / Weight

FROMM Puppy Gold Puppy Dry Dog Food

FROMM Family Puppy Gold Food for Dogs is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for gestation/lactation and growth.

  • A holistic approach to complete and balanced nutrition for dogs
  • Guaranteed Analysis: 27% MIN Crude Protein, 18% MIN Crude Fat, 5.5% MAX Crude Fiber, 10% MAX Moisture
  • Small pellets perfect for a puppy
  • Promotes a shiny coat
  • Expensive for size
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • For puppies and pregnant or nursing mothers.
  • Tastefully prepared with select proteins and wholesome ingredients
  • Enhanced with probiotics to aid digestion and salmon oil for a healthy coat
Product Dimensions / Weight

Instinct Puppy Grain

High protein, grain free dry dog food mixed with all natural bites of freeze dried raw meat, all in one bag.

  • Promotes strong teeth and bones plus natural DHA for brain & eye development
  • Made from real meat & whole food ingredients, protein packed & minimally processed
  • Some buyers report that their dog's fur, teeth, and overall health improved
  • Great for finicky eaters
  • Some report that this product caused their dog to have diarrhea or loose stools
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Grain free with freeze dried raw cage free chicken
  • Made with calcium & phosphorus
  • No grain, potato, corn, wheat, soy, by product meal, artificial colors or preservatives.
  • Also includes probiotics and omegas
Product Dimensions / Weight

Evanger's Grain-Free Dry Dog Food

Fresh de-boned Chicken as its first ingredient and uses nutrient-rich fruits and vegetables instead of grains for optimal canine health.

  • Evanger’s utilizes high-quality, inspected meats to make highly palatable and nutritious foods that will satisfy even the most finicky eater.
  • Makes an excellent mixer to dry foods.
  • Packaging doesn't hold up
Dog Life Stage
Key Features
  • Fresh Meat Is The First Ingredient No Corn, Wheat, Or Soy
  • All Life Stage Formulas For Your Puppy, Adult, Or Senior Dog
  • Top Approved Dry Food By The Whole Dog Journal
Product Dimensions / Weight

Dog Food Overview

Identifying the right food for your dog is not as easy as some might think. Their needs will differ based on age, breed, activity and even reproductive status. Not to mention that dogs, like humans may have certain allergies or intolerances that prevent them from eating certain foods. Therefore, it’s important to take the time to compare the many high quality commercial dog foods available. The good news is that dog food is highly regulated and has gone through rigorous testing by veterinary specialists before going to market.

While meat is a primary component of a dog’s diet, essential vitamins and minerals are also derived from fruits and vegetables. Likewise, nutrients can stem from healthy grains so remember that such ingredients are not just filler but rather an essential component of your dog’s diet. Unlike cats, Dogs are not strict carnivores.

The above comparisons identify the specific Dog Life Stage that the product was intended for and also outlines the key features and various pros and cons mentioned by actual purchasers of these products.

Understanding Your Dogs Needs

There are many things to look for when choosing the right Dog Food. You need to consider your dogs age, breed, activity levels, and overall health when deciding on the brand for you. Therefore it is important that you know what your dogs needs are and what to look for when reading the labels.

Puppies have different nutritional needs than older dogs and thus have different foods available. They require more calories to help them grow while older dogs need less to keep them within a healthy weight range. Also, highly active dogs require more calories than less active ones for obvious reasons so gauging that is also important.

Other things to consider are your dogs breed and health. Rarely is food made specific to a particular breed but bigger breeds need certain things while smaller breeds need other ingredients. Typically the differences are in kibble size but there are also choices to be made between dry and wet food and what nutrients are more or less important to your dogs health.

Ultimately, it is important to consult your Vet for what is best for your dog. They often have recommended brands and types of dog food so they will be able to direct you to what is best for you.